Olivie Blake wrote, “Art is whatever we say it is; it’s whatever is reflected by our choices. Nobody needs art until they need it. Until their heart breaks or they fall in love for the first time or they lose someone or they open the door to new and terrifying truths about themselves. Art is the sweat and the work. Art is the joy and pleasure of being alive.”
That speaks to me today.
I’ve struggled to define what this newsletter is for as long as I’ve been writing it. I think I’ve arrived at a place where I’m pretty comfortable with leaving it undefined, which is a relief. I don’t think it ultimately matters that some people call it a blog and some people call it a journal and some people call it a Substack and some people call it a newsletter. I don’t have a marketing team and I’m not actively seeking to expand its reach or whatever.
I started writing it in the aftermath of my deep frustration at the SB1 ballot initiative not receiving enough signatures to overturn that disastrous and shameful law here in Ohio. I felt like there had to be a way to grow a platform where I could convince people to work together on creating a community that worked better for all of us.
That served a need for me, because it got me writing and researching and expressing the thoughts that were previously in my head but that nobody except Kellie had heard me yelling about in our house.
When she died, though, I needed something very different. That “different thing” is whatever this newsletter has turned into. And if you trust Blake’s definition, it’s art. Even though it’s hard to convince myself I’m capable of producing capital-a “Art”, I’m trying to do so. If I write something that serves a need for myself, it’s art. Whether anyone else reads it or feels connected to it or not.
I have always taken a literalist approach to the question “If a tree falls in the forest and nobody is there to hear it, does it make a sound?” Because the answer is both yes and no—sound waves are generated by the tree falling, but if nothing with ears or sound wave-conducting skin or organs or whatever is nearby to translate them into meaning, then the concept of “a sound” is null and void.
So if I create something I consider to be art, and nobody ever reads it or views it or listens to it, is it still art? I think so. Especially if you trust Blake’s assertion that art is “what we say it is”. Anyone can argue with anyone else about what constitutes “good” art, but that’s beside the point. Art is art is art.
Maybe you feel like it’s ridiculous for me to spend so much time trying to interrogate this definition anyway, and that’s okay. A lot of it probably comes down to me trying to justify something I’m doing as meaningful enough or worthwhile enough, and that’s a me problem.
I’m trying, and sometimes think I’m making progress, but it’s never in a straight line. If I squint at it in the right light, my self-esteem looks healthier some days. If I focus on it too directly, it hides under a rock, so I still have to come at it sideways.
I remember a time when I felt far braver and much more self-assured. When I felt like most of my decisions had merit and that I could back them up if questioned. I remember a time when I felt like I had more to offer my friends. I remember a time when I didn’t feel the need to spend so much time thinking about when I wasn’t so weak and lonely and sad and comparing my present to my past.
I know the things in my life that have led me to feel this way. I could list the people who have tried to make me doubt my inner voice (and succeeded). I could tell you stories about who I might have been if I had support instead of criticism, nurturing instead of punishment, love instead of dismissal. Maybe those stories would be art too, but they wouldn’t be honest.
I am a product of all the people and events that have brought me to this place and time. Even though time isn’t real, and I’m not even sure if place is. Regardless of whether there are meaningful distinctions between “me” and “you”. It doesn’t matter whether I would have chosen most of the things that have happened to me, or chosen to have the people in my life who have built me up or torn me down (or both).
I have inhabited this body and this life for long enough to know when I’m happy, but not long enough to know how to consistently choose happiness without Kellie here. I have created art for long enough to know when I like it, but not long enough to know how to stop being scared to show it to anyone else (and, more importantly, to accept that it doesn’t really matter what anyone else thinks of what I’ve created).
Writing every day is a choice I make—not because art sometimes happens when we want it to or try hard enough or have enough skill or talent, but because our lives are art. We all get to choose what kind of art we’re making, if we’re lucky. I get joy and pleasure from my writing, and from my connections with my family and friends, and from a good sandwich. And, looking back over the course of my life, my relationship with Kellie has been the best, most resplendent piece of art I’ve ever co-created.
What did your art look like today? If nobody’s told you yet today, good job. I’m proud of you. Keep going.
XOXO,
Matt




Matt,
I find your writing to be quite wonderful. It is a gift for sure.
I find myself thinking about my journey through grief and I see little sparks of recognition.
Thank you